00:00
00:00
colorsCrimsonTears

211 Art Reviews w/ Response

All 402 Reviews

3 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

I'm glad it had such a positive effect on you!!!
You did amazing on your contributions!

Eldritchsaxes responds:

Thank you so much for the kind words! And for organizing this collab!! Been a while since I’ve had fun with pixel art

I've seen you post to the <5 thread a lot, and I just
wanna say your art feels super underrated to me.
You always make such great looking pieces!

Waterina responds:

Thank you

Order up!

Finasty responds:

Hello, what can i do for you

Idk the series, but amazing work in this!!
Edit:
Yeah I know the name lol.
I mean I'm not familiar with the game cause I haven't played it.

Finasty responds:

Lmao, there's already the name on the title, the series called "Honkai: Star Rail" basically a new game by mihoyo

The perspective is NUTS
Nice work dude!

BargonSpaceman responds:

Thanks!

Turned out awesome dood!
So many nice little touches~
I like the skull and hand placement, that's tricky to do well.

BargonSpaceman responds:

Thanks!

Very stunning. Reminds me of Twilight princess

artoast8p responds:

Thanks for the nice compliment!

Found you from the <5 thread, and I must say you have some impressive stuff!

ElChub responds:

I appreciate it :)

Yooo happy belated birthday dude!
You are getting better and better with your poses :)
(I seriously wish we got decent notifications on here)

Finasty responds:

You're 10 days late lol

As per request, I'm here dropping some feedback :)
I will critique 5 aspects of the piece and give
a half, whole, or no star depending on what I think of thought of that area.

So, for the character design itself, I'd give you a whole star.
They have a nice amount of detail without it being over complicated, which is great.
I don't see any areas that look too "busy",
or like they are there just because.

For the pose I give a half star.
It looks interesting, but it's kind of hard to read. Certain areas leave me a bit confused as to what's going on, like where her right arm goes to. Also, I assume she's sitting on the end of a hand rail? If so, her legs look like they are positioned a bit wonky to me.

For the composition I'd give a half star.
I can tell what's going on, but it doesn't read very well for me . Especially at the lower part of the image where things seem a little cluttered.

On your shading I'd give a half star.
It looks good in some areas, but in others it seems a little spotty. I enjoy the way you shaded the hair for example, but the shirt and legs don't seem to have received the same care.

For visibility I'll have to give a half star.
The second one looks a lot easier to see, but the initial one is pretty dark and hard to see.

Waterina responds:

Oh thank you for feedback

Btw im not the one who shaded the hair. My classmate want to shade the hair so I gave it to them

For What Are We But Ash
Amongst All This Gray Sand?

Joined on 1/18/18

Level:
31
Exp Points:
10,111 / 10,670
Exp Rank:
3,508
Vote Power:
7.22 votes
Audio Scouts
4
Art Scouts
5
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
> 100,000
Blams:
21
Saves:
29
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
57
Supporter:
4m 30d